Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Howard's avatar

I had just finished reading an article in The Economist entitle "Is being bilingual good for your brain?" when I received Gregory Garretson's note linking to this wonderful article! Many good tips (and links) here indeed! (That Economist article is here, BTW: https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2025/06/27/is-being-bilingual-good-for-your-brain)

Being a musician my natural tendency has been to apply methods for learning and mastering musical works to language learning. I suppose I tend to think that there is a lot in common between language and music: semantics, grammars, idioms, style, and endless room for nuance and interpretation. The short essay I wrote about my approach is here: https://leavingamerica.substack.com/p/a-musicians-perspective-on-language

Expand full comment
Rebecca Weston's avatar

I’ve heard the best way to learn a new language is to live with a partner who speaks it. But I happen to love my American husband, so that option was out for me when we moved to Spain together four years ago.

I started with Pimsleur which I highly recommend. I only did the first 30 lessons and then lost interest. But those first 30 gave me so much!

I then dropped into an online course that was self paced and helped a bit, but again lost interest.

And then, I found the holy grail: DreamingSpanish.com and the concept of comprehensible input. Can’t recommend it highly enough.

They say one of the reasons most of us find it difficult to learn a new language is that we are bored with traditional methods. Who among us really wants to go back to the school days of memorization and verb conjugations?

I’ve learned everything in the context of conversations and phrases. I’ve never conjugated a verb. I know how to speak in various tenses, but have never studied how to do so. All thanks to comprehensible input.

But the biggest thing for me was the fact that the videos on dreamingspanish.com were super interesting. I was learning about various places around the world, learning about the culture of Spain (and eventually Mexico, Argentina, Columbia). The videos are on topics of interest to adults. I still look forward to seeing what new videos they put up each day. Finding something that keeps your interest is key.

At first, I used the filter on the site to only listen to videos in Spain Spanish. But eventually, I got to the point where I could watch Spanish from speakers of other countries and recognize the differences. No grammar. No memorizing.

I dip into Madrigal’s Magic guide to Spanish once in a while to understand why things are the way they are and love to see how much I’ve progressed as I flip through that book and see the things I already know because I learned them naturally.

Totally agree that you need to put the time in. I started with a half hour every day. And then ramped up to two hours per day every day for two years. Sure, some days I only got a half hour in, but I stuck with it.

I’m at a level I’m very happy with at this point. I can communicate in Spanish effectively in most contexts. So now I only do a half hour a day.

Absolutely recommend finding something that works for you and is of interest to you. For me it was comprehensible input and dreamingspanish.com. I eventually got to the point where I could understand Español con Juan. And now I can watch YouTube content that’s created for native speakers, not just language learners. I also can listen to podcasts made by native speakers for native speakers.

I wish you all the best of luck with your language learning.

Expand full comment
37 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?